If a crash on River Road or New Bridge Road left you hurting worse than before, you deserve answers, not suspicion from an insurance adjuster. A New Milford car accident lawyer at Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. builds the medical and fault evidence your claim needs and pushes back when an insurer blames your pain on something else.
Call (201) 585-9111 any time, day or night, to talk with our team about your crash.
Can You Still Get Money for a Car Accident if You Had an Injury Before the Wreck?

You can still recover compensation in New Jersey when a crash worsens a condition you already had. The at-fault driver is responsible for the added harm, even if an earlier injury made you more vulnerable. What matters is proof of how your condition changed after the collision.
Insurers know many adults already have some wear in their necks, backs, or knees. They use that history to argue the crash caused nothing new. Our job is to show the before-and-after picture clearly.
Tell your doctor if you notice any of these changes after a collision:
- Pain that spreads to a new area, such as down an arm or leg.
- Numbness, tingling, or weakness you didn’t have before.
- Treatment that used to help but no longer works.
- New limits at work, at home, or during exercise.
These details belong in your chart from the first visit because the insurer will read every note your doctors write.
How We Prove the Change
Our New Milford car accident lawyers gather your records from before the crash, not just after it. When the earlier records show you working, exercising, or sleeping normally, and the later records show new limits, the comparison speaks for itself. Your treating doctors can then explain the difference in plain terms.
For a self-employed bagel store owner whose crash aggravated a prior low back injury, leading to surgery and post-traumatic stress, we recovered $750,000. In another case, an elderly couple injured in one crash and hurt again in a second crash months later recovered $1,170,000. Each case depends on its own facts, and past results don’t predict future outcomes.
Nothing but praise for Maggiano, DiGirolamo, and Lizzi. I have never seen such a fantastic display of teamwork at all levels of the firm. (As an aisde, everyone one who works at the firm was extremely courteous and kind – character traits that one would not typically associate with a law firm. )
Furthermore, the legal results brought about by Mr. Maggiano’s tireless litigation efforts on our behalf were very fair and just. If you ever find yourself in a car accident, be sure to consult Maggiano, DiGirolamo, and Lizzi.
Words cannot express how tremendously grateful I am to Mr. Lizzi for his sincere compassion and legal assistance during one of the most challenging times in my life. While coming highly recommended to me, Mr. Lizzi’s level of expertise and professionalism surpassed my greatest expectations. Regardless of the time or the importance of my matter, every phone call and email was promptly and personally returned. With each circumstance that arose, Mr. Lizzi gave practical advice and supplied necessary information to allow me to make my own informed decisions. The paralegals working with him kept in constant contact if any issues arose. Your office has been able to answer all of my questions and made me feel that I am important.
Simply put, lawyers like Mr. Lizzi are truly and exceptionally rare. I give the law firm of Maggiano, DiGirolamo, & Lizzi my highest recommendation, and should my family or I ever need assistance in the future, I will definitely give them a call.
The Office of Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi have been so helpful in my case that I just wanted to stress to anyone needing an attorney who has been in an accident that this office is the best. From the beginning of my case I was treated as number one. Mr. Maggiano and staff always kept me informed of the entire process of my case. I even had a driver, Juan, from their office, take me to my medical appointments because I no longer have an automobile. It just made me feel so much more relaxed. This is a law firm makes you feel right at home as soon as you come in. There were many times that I had questions and I would speak to Mariel, Mr. Maggianos’s paralegal and she would always be there to help
What New Milford Drivers Hear From Adjusters
Adjusters follow familiar scripts, and knowing them helps you avoid traps. Here are the excuses we hear most and how we respond:
| What the Adjuster Says | What’s Really Going On | How We Respond |
| “We just need a quick recorded statement.” | The company wants words it can use to limit your claim | Your lawyer handled all communication with the insurer |
| “Sign this form so we can get your records.” | A broad authorization can open your full medical history | Our team provides the records that matter, and nothing more |
| “Your MRI shows old degeneration.” | The insurer wants to blame your pain on age | We compare your records before and after the crash |
| “This offer expires Friday.” | A deadline pushes you to settle before you know your injuries | Your attorney values the claim on your medical timeline, not theirs |
None of these statements means the adjuster is acting in bad faith. They do mean the insurer is protecting its own bottom line, so you need someone protecting yours. That’s where Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. comes in.
What Is the Verbal Threshold in New Jersey?
Many New Jersey drivers chose the limitation on lawsuit option on their auto policies, which means you can sue for pain and suffering only if your injury fits one of six categories, such as a permanent injury or a displaced fracture.
Prior injuries make this harder because the defense will argue that the permanent damage existed before the crash. We ask your doctors to compare imaging and exams from both periods. That comparison often decides whether your claim clears the threshold.
Who Is at Fault for a New Milford Car Crash?
The driver whose carelessness caused the collision is at fault, and other parties can share the blame. An employer may be responsible when its driver was on the job, and a public entity may share fault for a dangerous road or a broken signal. Identifying every responsible party matters because each one may bring another insurance policy to the table.
New Jersey follows modified comparative fault, which means your recovery drops by your share of blame, and the state bars recovery if you were more than 50% responsible. If a jury values your losses at $120,000 and finds you 30% at fault, you would receive $84,000.
When the At-Fault Driver Lacks Enough Insurance
Many drivers carry only the state minimum of $35,000 per person in bodily injury coverage. If your losses run higher, your own Underinsured Motorist (UIM) coverage may fill part of the gap. Uninsured Motorist (UM) coverage on your policy can apply when the other driver has no insurance at all or flees the scene.
Verdicts and Settlements
$2,000,000 - Late Diagnosis
In his senior year of high school football, after undergoing a surgical rod repair of a displaced tibia/fibular fracture, a young man was the victim of medical negligence by the late diagnosis of a known complication of the surgery known as compartment syndrome, resulting in the loss of all tendons and muscle of his calf as well as osteomyelitis.
$425,000 - Fall From Ladder
Settlement under the New York Labor Law for a fall from a ladder by worker who suffered severe back injury.
$3,350,000 - Failure to Diagnose
Following an automobile accident, patient’s brain injury was undiagnosed by the emergency room physician. Subsequent emergency surgery failed to prevent significant brain damage which required prolonged rehabilitation and cognitive therapy. Patient now has long-term effect and requires the assistance of a walker.
Why Bergen County Trusts Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C.
Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. has collected more than $300 million for clients, and our attorneys belong to the Million Dollar Advocates Forum and the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum.
When you work with our New Milford car accident lawyers, you can expect honest advice, steady communication, and a Bergen County team that prepares your case as if it will go to trial.
Here’s how we can help:
- We study your full medical history so the insurer can’t surprise us with it.
- Your lawyer explains every offer and every risk before you decide.
- We work with your existing doctors and help you find care if you need it.
- Our team answers calls 24/7.
Whether your crash happened on a local New Milford street or a busy highway, our Hackensack car accident lawyers can help you pursue compensation. We also handle serious collisions throughout the county through our Bergen County car accident lawyer practice.
Call (201) 585-9111 to discuss your case with our team today.
Is There a Time Limit for Filing a New Milford Car Crash Claim?
In New Jersey, you generally have two years from the date of a car accident to file a lawsuit. Different rules apply to children, wrongful death claims, and claims against public entities, which usually require a written notice within 90 days.
Waiting also costs you evidence. If the insurer won’t pay fairly, we can file suit in the Superior Court of New Jersey at the Bergen County Justice Center in Hackensack.
FAQs: New Milford Car Accident Lawyer
How long does a car accident settlement take in New Jersey?
Many New Jersey car accident claims settle within several months to a couple of years. The timeline depends on how long your treatment lasts, whether the insurer disputes fault, and whether a lawsuit becomes necessary. Settling before your doctors understand your injuries usually costs you money.
Can I get my car repairs and rental covered after a New Milford crash?
You can usually recover the costs associated with repairing or replacing your vehicle. If you carry collision coverage, your own insurer may pay first and seek repayment later. Rental costs depend on the policies involved.
What if the police gave me a ticket after the crash?
A traffic ticket doesn’t decide who is at fault in a civil injury case. A guilty plea, however, can come up in the injury claim. Before you plead, ask the municipal court about a civil reservation, which keeps the plea out of the civil case.
Do I have to see a doctor that the insurance company picks?
Your insurer may ask you to attend an independent medical examination, often called an IME, as part of a PIP claim or a lawsuit. You generally must cooperate with a reasonable request. We prepare you for the exam and review the report the doctor writes.
Can I file a claim for a crash in a New Milford parking lot?
A parking lot crash can support a claim just like a crash on a public road. The same negligence and insurance rules apply, though fault often turns on who had the right of way in the lane or space. Photos and store video matter even more because police reports for lot collisions are sometimes brief.
Get a Clear Plan for Your New Milford Crash Claim
A prior injury shouldn’t stop you from getting paid for new harm someone else caused. Let Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. review your records, explain your options, and take on the insurance company for you. We’ll keep you informed at every step, from the first call to the final check.
Dial (201) 585-9111 or use our online contact form to get started. For a fall or other non-crash injury, ask about our New Milford personal injury lawyer services.
Fort Lee Office
Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C.
201 Columbia Ave
Fort Lee, NJ 07024
Phone: (201) 585-9111