A serious injury can turn your life upside down with constant pain, missing work, or struggling to do things that used to come easily. On top of that, medical bills and insurance disputes can add to an already difficult recovery. A New Milford personal injury lawyer at Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. can take on the legal burden while you focus on getting better.

We fight to hold the responsible party accountable and pursue the compensation you need to move forward. Our lawyers represent clients hurt in crashes, falls, bicycle collisions, and other accidents caused by someone else’s carelessness.

Call (201) 585-9111 at any hour to talk with our team.

What Injury Cases Do We Handle for New Milford Residents?

Our New Milford personal injury lawyers represent people seriously hurt by negligent drivers, unsafe property conditions, and other preventable accidents.

We handle cases involving:

  • Car, truck, and motorcycle accidents: We pursue claims against negligent drivers and other parties responsible for serious crashes.
  • Bicycle and pedestrian accidents: Our team represents cyclists and pedestrians struck by drivers who fail to yield, drive distracted, or break traffic laws.
  • Slip and fall accidents: We handle injuries caused by unsafe stairs, slippery floors, broken sidewalks, and other property hazards.
  • Dog bites and premises liability: Our attorneys help people injured by dangerous dogs and unsafe conditions on someone else’s property.
  • Wrongful death: We represent families seeking accountability and financial support after losing a loved one to negligence.

Our results show what that representation looks like for clients. In one bicycle accident case, a driver failed to yield and struck our client. A jury awarded $700,000, plus more than $42,000 in prejudgment interest. Although the driver’s insurance policy had a $250,000 limit, the insurer ultimately paid the full verdict.

Client Success Story
stars

I wanted to make sure that you were aware of my extreme gratitude to Chris DiGirolamo, and his law firm, for the work done on my behalf.

As a 33 year licensed motorcyclist in the state of NJ, I have seen a lot of friends/family go through the process of a personal injury suit, and many times the outcome is less than favorable.  Let’s face it, there is a lot of bias against bikers out there…  So when it was my turn to experience the process first hand, I didn’t hold a lot of hope that I would recover any of what I lost.

Chris DiGirolamo not only got me enough of a settlement to recover what was lost, he got the max available, allowing me to have a little piece of mind for the future as well.

He was patient when I sent endless emails full of questions and kind and understanding with regard to my case.  I will ALWAYS refer my friends to this firm, and use them again myself, if the situation ever arises…

Thank you again for all your hard work!

- Jennifer Bounassi

Client Success Story
stars

I want to express my deepest appreciation to the firm “MAGGIANO, DiIGIROLAMO
& LIZZI P.C. and to Cristopher DiGirolamo, in particular, for professionally and timely manner. The most important result for me is the successful completion of the case.

I also wish to express my thanks to the paralegal Nirelly Echanique and to Katty, the nice lady at the front desk.
Without any hesitation, I would recommend your firm to others.
Many thanks for your fruitful work.

- Eduard Arapov

Client Success Story
stars

I have been a practicing personal injury lawyer in New Jersey for over twenty years. I knew Michael Maggiano by reputation and when I was involved in an automobile myself I went to him to handle my case. I learned that the reputation was well founded and he has an outstanding law firm, very efficient and professional. He and his staff were always available and helpful during every step of the process and the resultant settlement was excellent. I could not recommend Mr. Maggiano and his firm more highly. Thank you to all at Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi .

- Kevin Decie

Bicycle and helmet on the road after a collision

How Fault Shapes a New Milford Personal Injury Claim

Fault decides both whether you can recover compensation at all and how much you receive. New Jersey uses modified comparative fault, which means your award shrinks by your share of the blame. If a jury finds you more than 50% responsible, you recover nothing.

That rule turns every percentage point into money. This example shows how a $200,000 jury award changes as the plaintiff’s share of fault rises:

Your Share of FaultRecovery
0%$200,000
10%$180,000
25%$150,000
50%$100,000
51%Nothing

Since the stakes are this high, insurers work hard to move some of the blame onto you. Your New Milford personal injury lawyer collects the proof that keeps your percentage low.

Common Ways Insurers Shift Blame

Defense lawyers rarely deny that an accident happened. Instead, they argue you contributed to it. Watch for claims like these:

  • You were looking at your phone or wearing headphones.
  • You weren’t wearing a helmet or seat belt.
  • You should have noticed the hazard before you fell.
  • You waited too long to get medical care.

Each argument has an answer when we gather the evidence early. Video, witness accounts, and prompt medical records are the strongest replies.

What if a Public Entity Caused Your New Milford Injury?

Team of personal injury lawyers at Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi P.C.
Team of Personal Injury Lawyers at Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi P.C.

Claims against a town, county, or state agency follow stricter rules than ordinary injury claims. New Jersey’s Tort Claims Act generally requires a written notice of claim within 90 days of the injury, and the state describes its notice of claim process online.

These claims also carry a higher bar for pain and suffering. To recover those damages from a public entity, you generally must show a permanent loss of a bodily function, permanent disfigurement, or dismemberment, and medical expenses above $3,600.

Public entities also have defenses that private property owners don’t, so these cases need careful planning from day one. Let our injury lawyers in New Milford take over that responsibility for you.

Examples of Public Entity Claims

A public entity may share responsibility when a municipal vehicle causes a crash, a county road defect contributes to an accident, or a dangerous condition on public property causes a fall. We identify the correct agency, file the notice on time, and preserve the records that the agency keeps.

Who Pays Your Medical Bills While Your Case Is Pending?

The answer depends on how you got hurt, and the wrong assumption can leave bills unpaid for months. In a car crash, your own PIP coverage usually pays medical bills first. After a fall or dog bite, your health insurance typically pays, and some homeowner and business policies include medical payments coverage that applies no matter who was at fault.

If you were hurt at work because of someone other than your employer or a coworker, you could have a personal injury claim in addition to workers’ compensation benefits. Our New Milford injury attorneys can handle both claims and work to reduce what you must repay so you can keep more of your recovery.

Why Repayment Claims Matter

Health plans and workers’ compensation insurers can claim a share of a settlement, while PIP carriers have separate reimbursement rights. We identify each of those claims early and challenge any amount that exceeds what the law allows. That work protects more of your recovery for you and your family.

Pedestrian walking a dog across a city crosswalk

When an Accident Takes a Loved One in New Milford

Losing a family member to someone else’s negligence is a grief no settlement can undo. New Jersey’s wrongful death law lets certain family members recover the financial support, services, and guidance their loved one would have provided. A separate survival claim can address what the person suffered before death.

Our New Milford personal injury lawyers handle these cases with patience and respect, and we take on the paperwork and the insurance calls so your family can grieve without that weight.

For the family of a car accident victim who died before emergency surgery could begin, we recovered $775,000. Every case is different, and past results don’t predict future outcomes.

Person's feet slipping on a wet sidewalk

The Difference Trial Lawyers Make for New Milford Clients

Insurers treat a case differently when they know the lawyer across the table will try it. Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. includes attorneys certified by the Supreme Court of New Jersey as Civil Trial Attorneys, a credential few lawyers hold.

Our Bergen County personal injury lawyers also represent clients throughout the county, bringing decades of experience to cases involving serious injuries, disputed liability, and insurance companies unwilling to pay fair compensation.

Here’s why we’re different:

  • Our firm earned recognition in Best Law Firms 2026 by Best Lawyers.
  • We’ve collected more than $300 million for injured clients.
  • We prepare each case for trial from the beginning.
  • You speak with your attorney directly, not a call center.

Our firm’s promise is simple: protecting the rights of the injured. That means we take the time to understand your daily life before we put a number on your claim. It also means we tell you when a settlement offer is fair and when it falls short, so every decision rests on real information.

Call (201) 585-9111 to talk about your claim with our team today.

Verdicts and Settlements

$817,500 - Total Disability

63 year old client was in the course of his employment as a driver for Benjamin Moore Paint and was doing his pre-drive inspection of his 18 wheel tractor trailer. It had snowed 8 inches about 3-4 days prior and the temperature had fluctuated above and below freezing, creating a melt, thaw and then refreeze in the parking lot where the tractor trailers were kept. It had…

$1,500,000 - Pedestrian Fatality

75-year-old pedestrian struck while crossing the street at her local library and eventually dies as a result of her injuries.   The driver claimed to have not seen the pedestrian prior to striking her and indicated she must not have been in the crosswalk.   Witness testimony at the scene indicated the pedestrian was in the crosswalk at the time and this office interviewed the witnesses and…

$245,000 - Slip & Fall

Permanent total disability award for 64 year old truck driver with a 20 year history of leg and back injury who slipped getting out of truck and twisted his knee and low back Got client lifetime award payments and medical benefits.

FAQs: New Milford Personal Injury Lawyer

What does pain and suffering include in a New Jersey injury case?

Pain and suffering in New Jersey covers the physical pain, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life that an injury causes. It has no fixed formula. Treatment records, testimony from family and friends, and your own account help show how the injury changed your days.

Can I bring a claim if a driver hit me while I was riding a bike in New Milford?

A cyclist hit by a careless driver in New Milford can bring a claim like any other injured person. Medical bills often start with PIP coverage from the cyclist’s own or a household auto policy. New Jersey requires helmets for riders under 17, and adult helmet use can still come up in fault arguments.

Can I switch lawyers if I'm unhappy with my current one?

You can generally change lawyers at any point in a New Jersey injury case. Your new firm requests the file from the old one, and any fee the first lawyer earned usually comes out of the final recovery rather than your pocket.

What should I bring to my first meeting with a New Milford injury lawyer?

Bring photos, insurance cards, police or incident reports, medical records, bills, and the names of any witnesses. A list of your symptoms and missed workdays also helps. Don’t worry if you’re missing items: we can request most records for you.

Can a family member sue for a loved one's injuries in New Jersey?

A spouse may have a separate claim for the loss of companionship and help at home caused by a partner’s injury. Parents usually bring claims for injured children. Other relatives generally have claims only when the injury causes a death.

Talk to a New Milford Personal Injury Lawyer About Your Case

You don’t have to face the insurance company or figure out your legal options on your own. Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C. can review what happened, explain your rights, and help you understand what compensation you could pursue. We’ll handle the legal work, deal with the insurers, and fight for a recovery that reflects the full impact of your injuries.

Our Hackensack personal injury lawyer team represents injured people in New Milford and surrounding communities. We bring decades of experience with Bergen County injury claims and know how to prepare cases when insurance companies refuse to offer a fair settlement.

Call (201) 585-9111 or contact us online to discuss your injury and how we can help.

Fort Lee Office
Maggiano, DiGirolamo & Lizzi, P.C.

201 Columbia Ave
Fort Lee, NJ 07024

Phone: (201) 585-9111